I’ve known people who played guitar who insisted that certain songs should be played on a specific guitar. Usually that sort of thing comes down to genre. People feel that if you play a hollow bodied guitar you should be playing jazz or blues. If you play a souped up Kramer strat copy with active pick ups you should be playing metal. I call bullshit on that. I’ve seen plenty of heavy rock gods playing hollow guitars, and I’ve heard a good amount of smooth jazz coming from 80’s era shred machines. No, your choice of guitar comes down to two things, tone and feel. Genre is irrelevant. If you like the way it feels in your hand, and you like the sound you get out of it, then it’s yours. This discussion isn’t about that.
Years ago, while playing in a band with Mike the bass player and Maria the drummer, I graduated to the upper echelon of guitar skill by finally being able to fudge my way through the opening riff to “The Spirit of Radio” by Rush. You know, that sick speed demon little bastard that all guitar players dream of being able to play when they first start out? I could get through it, though not cleanly and… well… not well. Yeah, I sounded like crap, but at least I could get through it and have it be recognizable. That was when I only owned one guitar, my Les Paul. A couple of years later I bought my ES-335 and I couldn’t play that riff. I attributed it to the action, as it’s a touch higher on the 335 and I thought that was the source of my problem. After that, I never really worried about it again.
Now in the new band there is one wicked easy 80’s song we do by the Greg Kihn Band. Dude, I really hope I’m spelling your name right. During my first practice with the band I had the ES-335 (Mike the bass player said that seeing me with that guitar instead of the Les Paul was just wrong. I don’t disagree, but I do love that semi-hollow little sucker). I played through the Greg Kihn song pretty well. Not great. Not terribly clean, but okay. After a few weeks I decided that Les Paul was my #1. The upside of the 335 was the ease in producing quality, usable feedback. The downside being that the intonation on the low E string is a little funny, and one song we do has a little chromatic scale that sounds out of tune even when the guitar is tuned up correctly. When playing the Les Paul, for some reason that stupid little Greg Kihn riff just kills me. I mess it up constantly. Really, I feel so embarrassed playing that damn song at rehearsal. Seriously, every time we play it I expect them to fire me. After that first practice I have never been able to do it well.
After the sad passing of BB King last week I decided that I would honor his memory in a way that no one on Earth would ever recognize, realize, or care about. I decided to play my 335 at this week’s practice. I put knew strings on it and then played through my nemesis, the Greg Kihn song, for a solid 20-30 minutes. Just playing that stupid four bar phrase over and over…
And I got it just about right every time.
That’s kind of peculiar.
Then it hit me. One of my problems was that I loop my thumb around to play the first fret on the low e-string. The neck on the Les Paul seems to be wider than on the ES-335. Is that the reason? Is that the problem? Is that why I can get through it pretty well on one guitar but constantly blow it on the other? We played it at rehearsal with me using the 335 and it went pretty well. I think I might be on to something. I think the ES-335 might have to make an appearance at every show we do. Because of the iffy intonation, I don’t think it can supplant the Les Paul as the #1, but maybe it means that I don’t have a single #1, I have two of them. Maybe we have to make sure the Aerosmith song (I hate them so) and the Greg Kihn song cannot be played in the same set, so a Kihn set can be played on one guitar, and an aerosmith set (I hereby refuse to capitalize their name) can be played on a different guitar.
And the Stratocaster stays at home and only gets used on home demos.