Which is Better

Here are two mixes of the same RPM left over.  Which one sucks the least?

Originally I wanted clean guitars under the verses and heavy guitars under the choruses.  By the time I put the vocals down I decided I didn’t like that idea anymore and I dropped the song.  Yesterday I re-did the guitars under the choruses with dirty, but not terribly heavy takes.  By the time I was done I kinda liked the song again.

After I finished mixing it today I sort of thought to myself that maybe I had it right the first time, so I did a mix with the original guitars.

So my question to you, dear readers, is which version sucks the least?